Why is ADHD controversial?
ADHD has become a controversial topic: some experienced clinicians and specialists believe the condition isn't adequately recognised, and so many children are not being diagnosed.
Others claim parents are pushing too hard to get their children a label and i
t's over-diagnosed.
So what are the problems?
Diagnosis
- There's no physical test (such as a blood test) for ADHD.
- No single cause has been established.
- There's no standardised method of assessment – it's down to the clinician whether he uses written tests or makes a judgement based on what you and the teachers tell him. What one expert would classify as ADHD, another might not. Although methods of assessment are increasingly standardised the final diagnosis of ADHD depends on clinical judgement that may vary from one specialist to another.
- Other problems can cause behaviour similar to ADHD, such as hearing problems, dyslexia, family problems, anxiety and depression.
- ADHD can exist with other conditions and this can complicate the assessment process. There are overlapping areas with conditions such as language difficulties, dyspraxia, sleep disorders, autism spectrum disorders and Asperger's Syndrome – this is increasingly recognised by most specialists however and will be taken into account during assessment.
- All children have problems with self-control to some extent – where do you draw the line between normal and difficult behaviour?
- Our modern lifestyle, with greater use of technology, means we're used to getting information quickly and in bite-size pieces. Some experts feel children have a shorter attention span because of this lifestyle, rather than because of a medical condition.
- ADHD services tend to be underfunded and overloaded, so it can take a long time to see a specialist and get a diagnosis.
History
In the past, researchers thought that ADHD was caused by:
- drug or alcohol abuse by the mother during pregnancy
- psychological trauma at an early age
- minor head injuries or brain damage.
The first two firmly put the blame on parents, but none of them took account of ADHD in children whose mothers didn't take drugs or drink heavily during pregnancy, had a settled family background and didn't have any brain damage.
Influence of the US
The US has a higher rate of diagnosis and medication than the UK. This is because:
- the definition of ADHD (used in the US) is wider than that of 'hyperkinetic disorder', which is the diagnostic term often used in the UK
- prescription guidelines are looser in the US, where stimulant drugs are prescribed for children under the age of six
- some US schools are insisting that children with ADHD must take medication or they will be excluded from school.
More UK specialists are using the American DSM-IV-TR definition now, so rates of diagnosis are also rising in the UK.
With a larger number of children being diagnosed, there's also a rise in the number of prescriptions for stimulant drugsmedications to treat ADHD.
Some experts feel that because the criteria for ADHD are wider, children may be misdiagnosed. But other experts, increasingly in the majority, think these issues surrounding diagnosis mean ADHD is still under-diagnosed.
Media
The media often seizes on one thing that sells news, and ADHD has become very controversial in the media. Common areas of controversy are listed below.
Causes
According to some sections of the media, ADHD is a result of bad parenting, poor discipline, watching too much TV and diet (particularly a large intake of E-numbers, or food intolerance).
Depiction of ADHD
How a child with ADHD behaves is often misrepresented. The media view is often that children with ADHD are bouncing off the walls and are out of control, destructive, malicious and antisocial. This description is more likely to be of a child with oppositional defiant disorder and conduct disorder.
Oppositional defiant disorder and conduct disorder are categories of behaviour that can exist with ADHD. But it doesn’t cause ADHD.
It's understandable that parents don't want their child to be diagnosed with ADHD, in case he or she is labelled as a troublemaker. But without the ADHD 'label', it's unlikely the child will get the help he needs.
Stimulant drugs
Some sections of the media are against the use of medication and claim parents are 'drugging' their children for an easy life.
Others claim, incorrectly, that Ritalin causes problems – such as brain damage and seizures, or turns children into 'zombies', with withdrawn, automaton-like behaviours.
This makes parents (and some specialists) wary of trying medication in case it causes more problems.
However, when doctors prescribe medication for a condition, there's usually a period of adjustment while they find the right dosage to suit the patient, and then there are regular reviews of the medication.
There are sometimes side-effects with medication, although these are largely predictable and seldom serious. If the specialist advising you is considering drug treatment, they should always discuss this with you.
Trendiness
ADHD is seen as being a 'trendy' disorder because diagnosis rates are rising.
Benefits scam
Because children with ADHD may be eligible for disability benefits, the media claims that greedy parents are pushing for a diagnosis so they can get extra money.
Stimulants and parenting
There are four big debates in this area.
- Are parents drugging children for an easy life?
- Are neurostimulant medications, such as methylphenidate, being overused? They used to be given to school-age children until adolescence, but are now being prescribed for younger children and for a longer period of time.
- Are older children misusing drugs, such as Ritalin? Ritalin is in the same drug category as amphetamines. It's claimed that in the US, older children who were having social problems and wanted to make friends sold their Ritalin in the playground. But with slow-release medication increasingly available, it's unlikely that children will have to take the drugs to school at all.
- Parental guilt surrounding medication. Parents worry that medication may make their child into a zombie or have terrible side-effects – are they bad parents for giving it to their child?
So where does that leave parents?
Parents can feel that whatever they do, they're in the wrong.
- If they don't get a diagnosis, their child will suffer.
- If they do get a diagnosis, they're either jumping on a trendy bandwagon or are bad parents, who are drugging their children to compensate for their own shortcomings.
The bottom line is ADHD is a medical disorder and it needs to be recognised and treated.
Drugs aren't the only treatment. They should only be prescribed alongside other treatments, such as counselling and behaviour therapy, together with appropriate school based strategies – and if necessary, practical and social support for the hardest pressed, if the specialist and other members of the ADHD team consider they will help.
Recent updates
For a detailed discussion and examination of the evidence for the validity of ADHD as a 'disorder', which it's possible to diagnose reliably, see the NICE Guideline 2009.
This confirms that ADHD symptoms consistently 'cluster' together in the population, causing impairment and showing a characteristic pattern of development and change over time – together with reliable evidence of genetic, environmental and neurobiological causation.
Labels:
adhd
Popular Posts
Blog Archive
- 2012 (6)
-
2011
(184)
- December(8)
- November(27)
- October(24)
- September(8)
- August(24)
-
July(61)
- Coeliac disease (coeliac sprue or gluten allergy)
- Asthma and allergy in winter
- Allergy
- How to make your home healthy
- The rise in allergies
- Testing times for children with food allergies
- How do doctors diagnose ADHD?
- Dealing with doctors Q&A
- My child may have ADHD – what next?
- Why is ADHD controversial?
- What causes ADHD?
- Symptoms of ADHD
- What is ADHD?
- Worried about your child's behaviour?
- Sprains and bruises
- Osteoporosis: preventing falls
- Prevention and treatment of osteoporosis
- Osteoporosis
- Osteomalacia and rickets (vitamin D deficiency)
- Gout (podagra or uric acid arthropathy)
- Influenza (flu)
- Costochondritis (Tietze's syndrome)
- Cold (common cold)
- Brittle bone disease (osteogenesis imperfecta)
- Back pain
- Giveaway of the Day - greenTech Plus
- Next Gen ILibrary
- Giveaway of the Day - HyperCam 3
- Arthritis
- Pain in the back
- The importance of posture
- Challenging the pain of arthritis
- Whiplash
- Stings and insect bites
- Sprained ankle
- Poisoning in children
- Penile injury
- Nosebleeds in children
- Nosebleeds (epistaxis)
- Toddlers – making your home safe
- Babies: how to make your home safe
- Heatstroke
- Heart attack – emergency first aid
- First aid – what everybody should know
- First-aid kit
- Dental injuries
- Concussion
- Carbon monoxide poisoning
- Burns
- ILibrary Competition Updated
- Giveaway of the Day - ShellBlast
- ILibrary : Jobs Feature
- ›› Pet allergies
- ILibrary Updated
- Giveaway of the Day - CubeDrift
- Why Should I Choose Blogger ??
- Wordpress Another Blog platform
- [Wall.fm] Create a Community For Free
- Type 1 Diabetes – Treated by Artificial Pancreas
- 10 Bad Skin Habits that can Damage Skin
- ILibrary Awards Updated...
- June(30)
- February(1)
- January(1)
- 2010 (2)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2011
(184)
-
▼
July
(61)
- Coeliac disease (coeliac sprue or gluten allergy)
- Asthma and allergy in winter
- Allergy
- How to make your home healthy
- The rise in allergies
- Testing times for children with food allergies
- How do doctors diagnose ADHD?
- Dealing with doctors Q&A
- My child may have ADHD – what next?
- Why is ADHD controversial?
- What causes ADHD?
- Symptoms of ADHD
- What is ADHD?
- Worried about your child's behaviour?
- Sprains and bruises
- Osteoporosis: preventing falls
- Prevention and treatment of osteoporosis
- Osteoporosis
- Osteomalacia and rickets (vitamin D deficiency)
- Gout (podagra or uric acid arthropathy)
- Influenza (flu)
- Costochondritis (Tietze's syndrome)
- Cold (common cold)
- Brittle bone disease (osteogenesis imperfecta)
- Back pain
- Giveaway of the Day - greenTech Plus
- Next Gen ILibrary
- Giveaway of the Day - HyperCam 3
- Arthritis
- Pain in the back
- The importance of posture
- Challenging the pain of arthritis
- Whiplash
- Stings and insect bites
- Sprained ankle
- Poisoning in children
- Penile injury
- Nosebleeds in children
- Nosebleeds (epistaxis)
- Toddlers – making your home safe
- Babies: how to make your home safe
- Heatstroke
- Heart attack – emergency first aid
- First aid – what everybody should know
- First-aid kit
- Dental injuries
- Concussion
- Carbon monoxide poisoning
- Burns
- ILibrary Competition Updated
- Giveaway of the Day - ShellBlast
- ILibrary : Jobs Feature
- ›› Pet allergies
- ILibrary Updated
- Giveaway of the Day - CubeDrift
- Why Should I Choose Blogger ??
- Wordpress Another Blog platform
- [Wall.fm] Create a Community For Free
- Type 1 Diabetes – Treated by Artificial Pancreas
- 10 Bad Skin Habits that can Damage Skin
- ILibrary Awards Updated...
-
▼
July
(61)
About Me
- Sidharth
- This is Sidharth, the proud admin of ILibrary. He is a student(+2) and aspires to be Popular..... He likes to Share his works and so here is the Platform Where he is going to share all his works.... Never miss out a post...... Follow us By email to keep yourself up to date !!!!